A high-profile UK podcast is drawing new attention to issues of justice, forgiveness and prison reform through the real-life story behind a transatlantic stage play currently playing in London’s West End. The latest episode of The Rest Is Politics: Leading, titled “Can the Justice and Prison System Really Change?,” examines the aftermath of the 2011 single-shot death of a young emergency worker and the unexpected journey of regret and reconciliation that followed.
The debate, which was released on YouTube on November 24, will be moderated by former Conservative Secretary of State for Prisons, Parole and Probation Rory Stewart, and Alastair Campbell, former Downing Street press secretary to former Labor Prime Minister Sir Tony Blair. A conversation with playwright James Graham and former prisoner Jacob Dunn explores the limits of traditional punishment, the potential for restorative justice, and whether there is still room for forgiveness in a polarized society.
Graham’s play Punch, which recently opened on Broadway and is currently playing at London’s Apollo Theater until November 29th before touring regional theaters, is an adaptation of Donne’s story from his memoir Right From Wrong: My Story of Guilt and Redemption. The article details how 19-year-old Dunn killed 28-year-old paramedic apprentice James Hodgkinson with a single punch in Nottingham in the early hours of July 30, 2011.
Tragedy occurred when Dan celebrated a friend’s birthday by consuming drugs and alcohol. Friends called to say there was trouble a short distance from a pub on Old Market Square in Nottingham, England. Dan joins them, looking for a showdown.
Mr Hodgkinson was watching cricket in Nottingham with his father and brother before an argument broke out and Mr Dunn punched him. He was taken to the hospital’s emergency room with a suspected brain injury and died nine days later.
A month later, police arrested Dunn on suspicion of murder. He was sentenced to four years in prison, but his sentence was reduced because he pleaded guilty to manslaughter and because he was young. He served 14 months in prison and was released on New Year’s Eve 2012.
But the story didn’t end there.
After his release, Dunn attended a restorative justice program run by an organization called Remedy, where he met the victim’s parents, Joan Scowfield and David Hodgkinson. Mr Stewart and Mr Campbell described them as “true heroes” for their difficult journey to seek forgiveness for the man who killed their son.
The story echoes another restorative justice outcome previously reported by Christian Daily International, when Australian Danny Abdallah and his family publicly forgave Samuel Davidson, the drunk driver who speeded on a Sydney road in 2020, killing three of Abdallah’s children and their cousin as they went to buy ice cream.
Graham said the themes of forgiveness and redemption at the heart of Punch deeply moved viewers. He attributed that influence to Hodgkinson’s parents, who he said performed “the most remarkable acts of forgiveness and compassion and kindness” during what he called “cruel or difficult times.” He added that the moment when Dunn met the victim’s parents was a powerful example of “coming together across the divide.”
“We always talk about division, and the worst division you can think of is when someone loses a son and they have to reach out to the person who took him in,” Graham said. He thought that the main challenge for the audience watching this play was to imagine whether they could forgive the murderer of their loved one under these circumstances.
Graham, who is known for his political drama, also noted that Donne’s story is similar to a “Dickensian story” about the limits of society’s “system.” According to the playwright, ex-convicts were unable to adapt to the court, prison and probation systems and grew up in a difficult environment.
Graham said Dunn’s story also highlights the harmful patterns of collective masculinity that shape many young people. Dunn explained that men between the ages of 18 and 25 often rely on a limited “emotional toolkit” and rely on behaviors learned in their environment rather than healthier alternatives to cope with pressure or search for meaning.
In Dan’s case, this usually led to drinking and fighting. For Graham, that meant crying, reading a book, and going to the local ice skating rink. Although they both came from similar working-class backgrounds, Graham had the advantage of parents who encouraged him to read and write and to pursue opportunities. So his emotional toolkit, the resources he relied on when under pressure as a young man, was healthier by comparison.
Dunn said people often asked the same predictable questions about the punch, the emotions that followed and life in prison. He felt little need to retell the story to strangers, thinking that some of the interest was “sometimes sensationalistic.” Instead, he said he wanted to foster a broader public conversation about the broader impact of his case and about justice and restorative justice.
Since then, he has co-founded the Common Ground Justice Project, which seeks to engage in constructive public dialogue on justice to “break the stalled public debate and find practical solutions to move it forward.”
Stewart pressed the podcast to explore issues of forgiveness and salvation. He named it “a major theme of our culture.” At one point, he wondered if those deemed “evil” really thought about the reality of their actions and the impact on others.
“I think we often seem very unforgiving,” Stewart said. “When you look at the headlines, you see that so-and-so is the bad guy, often a public figure, even a politician. They did something absolutely terrible, and they have a genuine motive. They have to be punished. They have to be held accountable.
“There’s very little room for the idea of forgiveness. There’s very little room to say that could have been me…This person will have a chance to change things…they’ll be forgiven. I feel like we’re a very vengeful, angry culture that wants to find someone to go after.”
Graham agreed, saying he saw the past 15 years in modern society as evidence of a drive for revenge rather than forgiveness. He said the discussion turned to competing and winning and being surprised by YouTube’s “thumbnail headlines.”
“Possessing, crushing and destroying is celebrated,” Graham said. Politicians are sometimes “praised for being bullies, for getting on top of people and winning that way. Rarely are they praised for sympathy and empathy.”
Dunn said that the story surrounding what happens after a crime is “stuck” and that the play reflects that by portraying characters who “don’t know how to move forward.” He noted that the victim’s parents were themselves trapped in their own grief, unable to get basic answers about how the victim had been in prison or whether they understood the impact of the harm he had caused.
He said Hodgkinson’s parents were refused even an answer by authorities at the time, citing “data protection” reasons, and were given no support as victims trying to find a way to “move on after losing their son”.
Dunn also said the prison system gives criminals little opportunity to express remorse, they have no chance to communicate with their victims and are often held for long periods without even realizing it.
In his own situation, as symbolized in the play, he personally felt stuck in a “bleak future” where he was “pessimistic about the world, didn’t believe he could participate in the job market where he could contribute, was unqualified, and had no fixed address upon release from prison.”
“When you widen that lens and look at the justice system, you start to see conversations that have been stalled for decades, like the prison crisis, overpopulation, and people being released early,” Dunn said. “And the debate about judicial reform is stuck in a ‘tough on crime, soft on crime’ perspective.”
Dunn also explained how restorative justice asks the right questions and looks at the needs of everyone involved in the crime and punishment situation. This goes hand in hand with finding space for everyone to participate in conversations “to find practical solutions that meet everyone’s needs.”
Mr Dunn said the loving care given to him by the victim’s parents who wanted him to make the most of his life, get an education and contribute to wider society really helped him find hope and progress in life.
Stewart then asked Dunn how he would respond to people who think he should continue to feel guilty for his crimes, or who question whether he has taken enough responsibility. “People may want you to feel guilty,” Stewart says. “How does forgiveness work in that case?”
“Why do humans find the concepts of forgiveness and moving on so difficult?” Stewart asked rhetorically.
In response, Dunn said that during Punch’s post-performance discussions, audience members often asked whether there was a Christian basis for the forgiveness shown by Hodgkinson’s parents. “Religion often talks about the need to forgive in order to move forward,” he says. But he gave a broader explanation, saying that forgiveness is “a gift we give ourselves so that we don’t get caught up and consumed by the bitterness, anger, and hatred that spills over to those around us.”
Mr Dunn explained that he chose to forgive the victim’s mother, Joan, after she “no longer recognized who she was”. She told him, “My son wouldn’t want me to become the person I’m becoming.”
“So the forgiveness for them was not motivated by a religious background,” Dunn said. “It was motivated by the need to live well or, as James[Graham]quotes in the play, ‘be the best version of yourself.'”
But Dunn couldn’t forgive herself and called it a “difficult journey.” He said it was a “life sentence” to look into the eyes of the victim’s parents and see their son’s sadness, adding: “Now I’m open to it and I can never forget it.”
“I can’t say I truly forgive myself,” he said. “And a lot of my work can be motivated by guilt, which is not a healthy thing, and the need to give back and the need to try to make an impact in the world, and the need to help young people, stop more fistfights, stop fighting common ground in public discourse, and try to get as much profit out of this story as possible.
“But it’s going to be a lifelong journey for me.”
